{
  "claim_scope": "paper_protocol_slab_itg_equivalent_growth_convergence",
  "collisionless_endpoint_relative_change": 0.005901406547628025,
  "collisionless_hierarchy": [
    {
      "frequency": -0.0879775171331797,
      "growth": 0.09487637153662667,
      "maximum_hermite_order": 4,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 1,
      "mode_count": 10
    },
    {
      "frequency": -0.09134612010356088,
      "growth": 0.08144705498558255,
      "maximum_hermite_order": 6,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 2,
      "mode_count": 21
    },
    {
      "frequency": -0.09975880071936107,
      "growth": 0.07574578702123627,
      "maximum_hermite_order": 8,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 4,
      "mode_count": 45
    },
    {
      "frequency": -0.10556228255366304,
      "growth": 0.07862913856307667,
      "maximum_hermite_order": 10,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 4,
      "mode_count": 55
    },
    {
      "frequency": -0.10556228255840454,
      "growth": 0.0786291385663325,
      "maximum_hermite_order": 10,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 6,
      "mode_count": 77
    },
    {
      "frequency": -0.10629933531552341,
      "growth": 0.08158300625684581,
      "maximum_hermite_order": 12,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 5,
      "mode_count": 78
    },
    {
      "frequency": -0.10285203589104763,
      "growth": 0.08323649347716383,
      "maximum_hermite_order": 15,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 6,
      "mode_count": 112
    },
    {
      "frequency": -0.10464943324890984,
      "growth": 0.08373062191758524,
      "maximum_hermite_order": 18,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 6,
      "mode_count": 133
    }
  ],
  "comparisons": [
    {
      "lower_resolution": [
        7,
        3
      ],
      "maximum_all_frequency_relative_change": 0.019117035816155693,
      "maximum_resolved_unstable_relative_change": 0.008774854224010567,
      "relative_growth_change": [
        0.018106828365767748,
        0.01815979333811533,
        0.01818400898891627,
        0.018218910159839098,
        0.01826876548501424,
        0.018339022700969296,
        0.018435969110428434,
        0.01856531486917283,
        0.018728360227603495,
        0.018913261454930996,
        0.01907745479774123,
        0.019117035816155693,
        0.018825512840787168,
        0.017871538378034412,
        0.015881467117481677,
        0.012717239302404376,
        0.008774854224010567,
        0.004815603562532319,
        0.001371134194421934,
        0.0015182875082775486,
        0.0038004494756027083,
        0.0048194514149758234,
        0.0039004917642885897,
        0.0030128817299472288,
        0.0005488314333843843,
        0.00014845325968852692,
        0.00012187958711921681,
        8.797755576351166e-06,
        2.9414081479990444e-06,
        1.568443515125103e-06,
        6.878851040191837e-07,
        3.969005268025406e-07
      ],
      "upper_resolution": [
        9,
        4
      ]
    },
    {
      "lower_resolution": [
        9,
        4
      ],
      "maximum_all_frequency_relative_change": 0.07439802232985072,
      "maximum_resolved_unstable_relative_change": 0.0011805584701031309,
      "relative_growth_change": [
        0.07439802232985072,
        0.07341921007005148,
        0.07296516236810958,
        0.0723031497406623,
        0.0713410151645558,
        0.06994940147106413,
        0.06795108321746679,
        0.06511268820203853,
        0.06114709277491399,
        0.055743135022736985,
        0.04864873820378604,
        0.03983192626336702,
        0.029705095765387247,
        0.019298413294778324,
        0.01014451384376938,
        0.003657213398421134,
        0.00023797630877976344,
        0.0009690366122801235,
        0.0011805584701031309,
        0.0010172281036400584,
        0.0006054000060113958,
        0.00019790666373306685,
        0.000416680392461929,
        0.0023908151317911957,
        0.00042944358955796576,
        2.419732478179194e-05,
        1.9686001185436815e-06,
        5.48764135396304e-07,
        3.16521653215481e-07,
        8.745056796590558e-08,
        2.433199522112237e-08,
        5.87622022896676e-09
      ],
      "upper_resolution": [
        12,
        5
      ]
    },
    {
      "lower_resolution": [
        12,
        5
      ],
      "maximum_all_frequency_relative_change": 0.019864931248835725,
      "maximum_resolved_unstable_relative_change": 0.0003710901893210905,
      "relative_growth_change": [
        0.019864931248835725,
        0.019411905091085924,
        0.019202608937742192,
        0.018898428445577264,
        0.018458441840356637,
        0.01782651878845692,
        0.01692857798856763,
        0.015673157668842478,
        0.013960970415355885,
        0.01171364552830901,
        0.008934906987101478,
        0.005807274159088238,
        0.0027801206754116702,
        0.0005137353153645844,
        0.00047669006535001136,
        0.00032317850259720797,
        0.00018775927861159204,
        0.0003710901893210905,
        0.00021467498922450378,
        7.3289533566191695e-06,
        0.00014965137628929185,
        0.00025043117407671204,
        0.00028051259703303603,
        0.0001023466157603397,
        2.0219444372008056e-05,
        3.306517066838743e-06,
        6.956155526169063e-07,
        2.1645337162045237e-09,
        4.253881432608225e-09,
        2.7020857000634216e-09,
        1.3461336511296395e-09,
        5.122544375458622e-10
      ],
      "upper_resolution": [
        15,
        6
      ]
    }
  ],
  "curves": [
    {
      "bessel_argument": 0.7071067811865476,
      "collision_frequency": [
        0.0,
        0.0001,
        0.0001467799267622069,
        0.00021544346900318845,
        0.00031622776601683794,
        0.00046415888336127773,
        0.0006812920690579609,
        0.001,
        0.0014677992676220691,
        0.002154434690031882,
        0.0031622776601683794,
        0.004641588833612777,
        0.006812920690579608,
        0.01,
        0.01467799267622069,
        0.021544346900318822,
        0.03162277660168379,
        0.046415888336127774,
        0.06812920690579609,
        0.1,
        0.1467799267622069,
        0.21544346900318823,
        0.31622776601683794,
        0.46415888336127775,
        0.6812920690579608,
        1.0,
        1.4677992676220675,
        2.154434690031882,
        3.1622776601683795,
        4.641588833612772,
        6.812920690579608,
        10.0
      ],
      "frequency": [
        -0.10861650369064996,
        -0.10856677639688483,
        -0.10854353264875656,
        -0.10850943723352753,
        -0.10845943931633986,
        -0.10838615579736015,
        -0.10827881760031227,
        -0.10812177044303344,
        -0.10789238500324147,
        -0.10755825254833357,
        -0.10707370104259595,
        -0.10637619841036874,
        -0.10538460496483455,
        -0.10400415032032248,
        -0.10214669104507285,
        -0.09977130118713795,
        -0.09692079109698352,
        -0.09368580629826789,
        -0.09006931187862205,
        -0.08585652115582762,
        -0.08059814210995436,
        -0.07362228288489182,
        -0.06376882613160957,
        -0.04843818287986317,
        -0.020699687291850705,
        0.16429210578557135,
        0.152525979377074,
        0.1632554172159259,
        0.17038182570927776,
        0.17448161341361818,
        0.17662932149094304,
        0.17769076369357206
      ],
      "growth": [
        0.08923973153469601,
        0.08918809896016498,
        0.08916404329231414,
        0.0891288469538297,
        0.08907742700202682,
        0.08900246848302623,
        0.08889354278757895,
        0.08873598897774199,
        0.0885096246916231,
        0.08818753970088235,
        0.08773558522506322,
        0.0871137277837129,
        0.08628092214887409,
        0.08520433771669068,
        0.08386823886171554,
        0.08226320294546986,
        0.08032248454476255,
        0.07780223579665708,
        0.07417088044985519,
        0.0685473709785974,
        0.059625506400746126,
        0.04549453811923584,
        0.023320746853767237,
        -0.011120624974521763,
        -0.06474292008221039,
        -0.12753088102163587,
        -0.08095555642820908,
        -0.08450716528032232,
        -0.11059956093886354,
        -0.15698838997333148,
        -0.22826424943464133,
        -0.3341076123025791
      ],
      "maximum_hermite_order": 7,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 3,
      "mode_count": 32,
      "paper_kperp": 0.5
    },
    {
      "bessel_argument": 0.7071067811865476,
      "collision_frequency": [
        0.0,
        0.0001,
        0.0001467799267622069,
        0.00021544346900318845,
        0.00031622776601683794,
        0.00046415888336127773,
        0.0006812920690579609,
        0.001,
        0.0014677992676220691,
        0.002154434690031882,
        0.0031622776601683794,
        0.004641588833612777,
        0.006812920690579608,
        0.01,
        0.01467799267622069,
        0.021544346900318822,
        0.03162277660168379,
        0.046415888336127774,
        0.06812920690579609,
        0.1,
        0.1467799267622069,
        0.21544346900318823,
        0.31622776601683794,
        0.46415888336127775,
        0.6812920690579608,
        1.0,
        1.4677992676220675,
        2.154434690031882,
        3.1622776601683795,
        4.641588833612772,
        6.812920690579608,
        10.0
      ],
      "frequency": [
        -0.10450979309869239,
        -0.10447775802641648,
        -0.10446276546220079,
        -0.10444075225266918,
        -0.1044084268997695,
        -0.10436095189264075,
        -0.10429121771546127,
        -0.10418878322827847,
        -0.10403835151931133,
        -0.10381765161562924,
        -0.10349472100006492,
        -0.1030250647676201,
        -0.1023503984926075,
        -0.10140261533991073,
        -0.10011614520670273,
        -0.0984402950112294,
        -0.09632323450579457,
        -0.09366045846474313,
        -0.09027468402638848,
        -0.08596869184155038,
        -0.0805294731783716,
        -0.0735044184784972,
        -0.06372046114477314,
        -0.04843707751482226,
        -0.02068846529119115,
        0.16436084115988506,
        0.1525220731539746,
        0.16325309963714602,
        0.17038091818809123,
        0.17448108373582247,
        0.17662884593869077,
        0.17769028329073056
      ],
      "growth": [
        0.08765262057807897,
        0.08759734920169547,
        0.08757163980689149,
        0.08753407156800724,
        0.08747928839749702,
        0.08739964441995209,
        0.08728437082325818,
        0.08711860465142529,
        0.08688245870748935,
        0.08655058584177933,
        0.086093147102814,
        0.0854796109986997,
        0.08468665248507307,
        0.08370834088991498,
        0.08255711082089914,
        0.0812301793165244,
        0.0796237973304259,
        0.07742936666271151,
        0.07406932147042945,
        0.06865160385114781,
        0.059852974606703434,
        0.045714858659487725,
        0.023412065422131246,
        -0.011154231354380982,
        -0.06477847254414924,
        -0.12754981620762457,
        -0.08096542446071328,
        -0.08450790876024786,
        -0.11059923562137072,
        -0.15698814374629547,
        -0.22826409241517237,
        -0.3341074796951444
      ],
      "maximum_hermite_order": 9,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 4,
      "mode_count": 50,
      "paper_kperp": 0.5
    },
    {
      "bessel_argument": 0.7071067811865476,
      "collision_frequency": [
        0.0,
        0.0001,
        0.0001467799267622069,
        0.00021544346900318845,
        0.00031622776601683794,
        0.00046415888336127773,
        0.0006812920690579609,
        0.001,
        0.0014677992676220691,
        0.002154434690031882,
        0.0031622776601683794,
        0.004641588833612777,
        0.006812920690579608,
        0.01,
        0.01467799267622069,
        0.021544346900318822,
        0.03162277660168379,
        0.046415888336127774,
        0.06812920690579609,
        0.1,
        0.1467799267622069,
        0.21544346900318823,
        0.31622776601683794,
        0.46415888336127775,
        0.6812920690579608,
        1.0,
        1.4677992676220675,
        2.154434690031882,
        3.1622776601683795,
        4.641588833612772,
        6.812920690579608,
        10.0
      ],
      "frequency": [
        -0.10629933531552341,
        -0.10622033593940416,
        -0.10618384888613343,
        -0.10613082308418162,
        -0.10605410948558179,
        -0.10594384352682745,
        -0.10578680031214985,
        -0.10556597778756573,
        -0.10526079154961726,
        -0.10484829037578088,
        -0.10430528507592828,
        -0.10360972152546177,
        -0.10273750685477978,
        -0.10165156765271621,
        -0.10028772185997334,
        -0.09855298924809615,
        -0.09634524476681351,
        -0.09356885432375138,
        -0.09011500378521582,
        -0.08582823829697471,
        -0.08045849553150214,
        -0.07348687270254085,
        -0.0637170203951509,
        -0.048433664650460305,
        -0.020693411695546296,
        0.16436293661024579,
        0.15252200904724544,
        0.16325315182140127,
        0.17038090384041496,
        0.17448105532916727,
        0.1766288154530115,
        0.17769025229722435
      ],
      "growth": [
        0.08158300625684581,
        0.08160590790617475,
        0.08161648008553672,
        0.08163183292819522,
        0.0816540085362646,
        0.08168577345787294,
        0.08173068242067083,
        0.08179285217086812,
        0.08187598052998529,
        0.0819807233128874,
        0.08209912811250944,
        0.08220521878556897,
        0.08224359851509219,
        0.08212348787960563,
        0.08172801979268836,
        0.08093418572808933,
        0.07960485326128583,
        0.07750447133304865,
        0.07415686798905025,
        0.0687215093017341,
        0.059889231547842516,
        0.04572390772551852,
        0.023421824837296625,
        -0.011127627254759371,
        -0.06475066578580792,
        -0.12755290264663677,
        -0.08096526507248286,
        -0.08450795513518279,
        -0.1105992706284347,
        -0.156988157474999,
        -0.2282640979692933,
        -0.33410748165843357
      ],
      "maximum_hermite_order": 12,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 5,
      "mode_count": 78,
      "paper_kperp": 0.5
    },
    {
      "bessel_argument": 0.7071067811865476,
      "collision_frequency": [
        0.0,
        0.0001,
        0.0001467799267622069,
        0.00021544346900318845,
        0.00031622776601683794,
        0.00046415888336127773,
        0.0006812920690579609,
        0.001,
        0.0014677992676220691,
        0.002154434690031882,
        0.0031622776601683794,
        0.004641588833612777,
        0.006812920690579608,
        0.01,
        0.01467799267622069,
        0.021544346900318822,
        0.03162277660168379,
        0.046415888336127774,
        0.06812920690579609,
        0.1,
        0.1467799267622069,
        0.21544346900318823,
        0.31622776601683794,
        0.46415888336127775,
        0.6812920690579608,
        1.0,
        1.4677992676220675,
        2.154434690031882,
        3.1622776601683795,
        4.641588833612772,
        6.812920690579608,
        10.0
      ],
      "frequency": [
        -0.10285203589104763,
        -0.10286166223358095,
        -0.10286578146150886,
        -0.10287139412118322,
        -0.10287871889044337,
        -0.10288756537577098,
        -0.10289663870241485,
        -0.10290210290715793,
        -0.10289486797881035,
        -0.1028560244627278,
        -0.1027504145988859,
        -0.10252023401871992,
        -0.10208373887794218,
        -0.10134487666038548,
        -0.10021065407437064,
        -0.098599464174936,
        -0.09643460495242383,
        -0.09364237595364172,
        -0.09014855347820701,
        -0.08583768517630079,
        -0.08046698267138032,
        -0.07349685695413889,
        -0.0637217767513749,
        -0.04843428304284099,
        -0.020693414023009494,
        0.16436119291045606,
        0.15252202649486923,
        0.16325315119868616,
        0.17038090254616284,
        0.1744810549375428,
        0.1766288154824388,
        0.17769025251325288
      ],
      "growth": [
        0.08323649347716383,
        0.08322139370227113,
        0.0832144139343005,
        0.08320426273383766,
        0.08318955815723489,
        0.08316837607660804,
        0.08313809209654796,
        0.08309521660220104,
        0.08303523296078297,
        0.08295239830232393,
        0.0828392894587005,
        0.08268539554645991,
        0.08247288308251069,
        0.08216569930104821,
        0.08168907942008122,
        0.0809080379895238,
        0.07961980261798858,
        0.07753324315893118,
        0.07417279103216583,
        0.06872201296216167,
        0.05988027038296713,
        0.0457124599005157,
        0.02341525656286798,
        -0.01112876624632227,
        -0.06475197503476511,
        -0.12755332440388084,
        -0.08096520875182443,
        -0.08450795495226247,
        -0.11059927109891089,
        -0.15698815789919446,
        -0.2282640982765673,
        -0.3341074818295816
      ],
      "maximum_hermite_order": 15,
      "maximum_laguerre_order": 6,
      "mode_count": 112,
      "paper_kperp": 0.5
    }
  ],
  "gate_passed": true,
  "gates": {
    "collisionless_p15_p18_converged": true,
    "equivalent_growth_convergence_reached": true,
    "intermediate_collision_range_converged": true,
    "literature_resolution_reached": false,
    "low_collisionality_growth_converged": true,
    "paper_wavelength_reproduced": true
  },
  "literature_reference": "Frei, Hoffmann & Ricci (2022), equations (2.14)--(2.18) and Figure 16",
  "literature_required_resolution": [
    18,
    6
  ],
  "protocol": {
    "bessel_argument": 0.7071067811865475,
    "eta": 3.0,
    "geometry": "homogeneous slab",
    "kparallel": 0.1,
    "paper_kperp": 0.5,
    "resolved_collision_minimum": 0.03,
    "tau": 1.0
  },
  "schema_version": 2,
  "thresholds": {
    "collisionless_endpoint_relative_tolerance": 0.01,
    "nested_growth_relative_tolerance": 0.05
  }
}